Isla and the Happily Ever After (#3) by Stephanie Perkins

Published: 14 August 2014 (print)/14 August 2014 (audio) Goodreads badge
Publisher:
Dutton/Books on Tape
Pages: 339/8 hrs and 37 mins
Narrator: Grace Experience
Format: Audiobook
Genre: Young Adult Romance
★   ★  – 2 Stars

Hopeless romantic Isla has had a crush on introspective cartoonist Josh since their first year at the School of America in Paris. And after a chance encounter in Manhattan over the summer, romance might be closer than Isla imagined. But as they begin their senior year back in France, Isla and Josh are forced to confront the challenges every young couple must face, including family drama, uncertainty about their college futures, and the very real possibility of being apart.

Featuring cameos from fan-favorites Anna, Étienne, Lola, and Cricket, this sweet and sexy story of true love—set against the stunning backdrops of New York City, Paris, and Barcelona—is a swoonworthy conclusion to Stephanie Perkins’s beloved series.

I can’t really complain, it does what it says on the tin, it is a happily ever after. It’s a book of a perfect romance and a perfect love. Can’t really argue with that.

But I am still going to.

I disliked it from quite early on. I don’t know whether it was Isla’s voice or when I realised it was all falling into a perfect set of circumstances. I know it’s a romance, but even the romances I have read don’t lay it on so thick.

It is saccharine and aside from that technically there was nothing wrong but it felt uneventful. Isla and Josh have always loved each other, they get to be together, everyone is ok with it. The minor issues are barely issues and are overcome, and nothing bad ever happen. So much so something has to be fabricated to have some kind of conflict but it felt hollow. Like Perkins needed to have something bad before she wrote a book that sounded like a fairy tale romance. But even a fairy tale romance has some kind of real drama to overcome.

So we put up with this everything is perfect for the first half of the book, and by now I am begging for something to happen. Not dire, but some real conflict or consequential plot. I ended up skipping chunks, even the promise of cameos from other characters in the series wasn’t enough to keep me going. They are a blink and you’ll miss it moment so they may as well not be there. I ended up skipping through a lot of the second half of the book. Which from what I’ve read is more of Isla being utterly obsessed with Josh and their relationship and having no other personality.

I’m pretty sure I liked Josh on his own, but I needed him to stop treating Isla like a perfect and innocent person. Isla even does it herself by mentioning how she shocks people when she swears because no one expects someone so petite to swear. What does that even mean?

I did like how Isla and Kurt’s friendship was demonstrated. I liked how she fought for him, and stood up for their relationship. I also liked how she took him for granted, it gave some realism to the story about how knowing him for ages meant she sometimes became selfish and overlooked his needs. It was a nice break from the lovefest. I needed more of Kurt in the book though because Isla was exhausting and Josh and Isla together were exhausting.

Having someone knocked up on pain meds is a great way to break through the shyness barrier and have your characters confess things to each other, but the story needed to bring itself down to earth for the rest of the story. Even though the ending was ok, I didn’t have any interest in them because of course everything was going to work out for both of them. Everything was fixed and they were living their best lives. At least there was a small amount of growth you could point at.

You can purchase Isla and the Happily Ever After via the following

QBDDymocks | Booktopia

WorderyBlackwell’s | Angus & Robertson

Fishpond | Amazon | Amazon Aust

Every Last Suspect by Nicola Moriarty

Published: 04 June 2024 (print)/04 June 2024 (audio) Goodreads badge
Publisher:
HarperCollins Australia/Bolinda Publishing
Pages: 384/8 hrs and 56 mins
Narrator: Claire Warrillow, Eva Seymour, George El Hindi, Jessica Stanley
Format: Audiobook
Genre: Domestic Thriller/Mystery
★   ★   ★ – 4 Stars

Complicated, driven, loving. Manipulative, irresistible, monstrous.

Love or hate her, Harriet Osman is impossible to turn down. But someone in her life has finally snapped, leaving her lying in a pool of her own blood. Harriet isn’t one to die quietly though, and she is determined to reveal her killer before she goes.

Was it her devoted husband, Malek, with a violent past? Her best friend and lover, Victoria, with a deadly secret only Harriet knew? Or the new woman in her life, fellow school mum Karen? The one with an impeccable reputation … or so she says.

Bullying, friendships and games (in and out of the bedroom) combine with envy, lust and revenge, creating a darkly twisted tale of drama and suspense where the question isn’t who killed Harriet, but why did it take them so long?

I recently heard Moriarty speak at the Newcastle Writers’ Festival and was intrigue by her new book. I’ve enjoyed her books in the past and the premise was interesting and a different way to approach a mystery and a whodunit. The victim uses her dying moments to try and work out who has killed her. Who would have a motive to harm her? If only it could be figured out before she died then maybe she could leave a clue to those who find her. It piqued my interest and I was curious to see how it played out, especially Moriarty’s discussion about having a character who was unlikable, but balanced to also gain sympathy from readers.

I enjoyed the breakdown of the points of view, the three suspects Harriet believes could be her murderer. As we get each perspective we see how Harriet has influenced their behaviour and impacted on their lives in ways even they couldn’t imagine.

One thing I love about well done mysteries is having characters who can be complicated enough to have depth and feel real on the page, but also needing enough motive and be the kind of person who could kill someone. Moriarty does this incredibly well because as these lives play out in the Western Suburbs, the almost parasitic way Harriet has infiltrated their thoughts and their lives is enough to make you think they have a chance to risk everything to get payback.

The possible motives of the characters are fantastic and I loved the complexity and unique way everything is revealed. The surprise/non surprise party for Harriet is a great way to gather everyone and I loved how it’s a jumping off point to set things in motion as well as bring everything to a head.

The representation of messy families, jealousies, fears, hidden pasts, and semi toxic friendships is wonderful and nothing ever felt false or overdone. Each character brings their history and personality to the story and you could feel their real lives being impacted by Harriet and her actions.

I loved how complex Harriet was. She is a mean girl, a toxic friend, a person everyone loved and wanted to be friends with but could also burn you at the slightest thing. She was flawed but not entirely bad either and having her deductions in her own head as she dies it gives us an insight into her motives that beautifully contrast how those motives are perceived by everyone around her. Her flaws and own short comings make her be perceived in a harsh light, more than she intends, but she is also in no way completely innocent either. Moriarty has balanced her wonderfully.

The ending is deeply satisfying because not only is the revelation fantastic, the wrap up is incredibly clever. Things you don’t think are important come back, and things that felt important weren’t or they are in a different way. Unconnected things become connected and there’s misleads and expectations that don’t come to light. All the while making you think if some things had been discovered sooner would they have made a difference? You’re never really sure and it’s a great thing to leave readers thinking about.

You can purchase Every Last Suspect via the following

QBDDymocks | Booktopia

WorderyBlackwell’s | Angus & Robertson

Fishpond | Amazon | Amazon Aust | Audible

 

 

Lovebird Lou by Tammi Sauer

Published: 1 March 2022Goodreads badge
Publisher:
Union Square Kids
Illustrator: Stephanie Laberis
Pages: 32
Format: Picture Book
★   ★   ★   ★  – 4 Stars

A sweet, love-infused celebration of individuality and acceptance!

Lovebird Lou adores life with his family and friends on the island they call home. But when he travels to the other side of the island and sees the amazing abilities on display by different birds, Lou feels unfulfilled with the laidback lovebird lifestyle. With his adoring parents cheering him on, Lou decides to spread his wings and see what else he can accomplish. This sweet, funny story celebrates individuality, self-discovery, and the joy of community.

Another picture book I picked up for the cover and it 100% delivers internally as well. This is a wonderful book. It is funny, cute, and the illustrations are half the fun. I liked how Lou isn’t unhappy with being a lovebird, but he still wants to be more interesting and these new birds he hasn’t seen before are what he wants to become.

I loved how unequivocally supportive Lou’s parents are. He wants to be a flamingo, they are right behind him, he wants to be a pelican, they tell him he’s an amazing pelican. There are brilliant lines as Lou admits defeat in his quest to be a [different] bird, “Being a bird is for the birds” he admits and becomes a rock. This was the highlight of this book for me. There is nothing more adorable than a flock of supportive lovebirds helping this little bird start his journey to be a rock. There is nothing more fantastic than the greatest image ever of a bird sitting in a field with a sign beside him that reads #1 Rock. Laberis has added so much to this story with the illustrations and as much as I love Sauer’s story, the illustrations are divine.

You can purchase Lovebird Lou via the following

QBD | Blackwell’s

Dymocks | Wordery | Angus & Robertson

 Fishpond | Amazon | Amazon Aust

Lola and the Boy Next Door (#2) by Stephanie Perkins

Published: 1 June 2011 (print)/11 October 2011 (audio) Goodreads badge
Publisher:
Usborne Publishing/Books on Tape
Pages: 384/8 hrs and 59 mins
Narrator: Shannon McManus
Format: Audiobook
Genre: Young Adult Romance
★   ★   ★ – 3 Stars

Lola Nolan is a budding costume designer, and for her, the more outrageous, sparkly, and fun the outfit, the better. And everything is pretty perfect in her life (right down to her hot rocker boyfriend) until the Bell twins, Calliope and Cricket, return to the neighborhood. When Cricket, a gifted inventor, steps out from his twin sister’s shadow and back into Lola’s life, she must finally reconcile a lifetime of feelings for the boy next door.

I am well behind the hype for Perkins’ series, though I did experience all the Anna hype at the time, it took me a few more years before I got a chance to read it. But then I never continued with the series. I’m not sure whether Anna didn’t drive me enough to want to keep reading, or it was one of those ‘one day’ books and then suddenly years have passed. The important thing is, I was not a fan.

I don’t think enough was put on the fact twenty one year old Max got together with Lola at sixteen. I know Lola is our perspective so it’s not going to be balanced but I didn’t like it. By the time the story starts Lola is seventeen, Max is twenty two, and they’ve been dating a year was a surprise, I thought it was relatively new. I couldn’t understand why a guy in a band, who tours the country, old enough to drink and be in bars would be ok dating a sixteen year old. One still in high school, with all the childish drama, and be happy with that? It’s not like he was eighteen or nineteen. Are we meant to think it was because he really cares about her? It adds another level when he starts calling her Lolita and all the red flags already raised are suddenly waving around.

Lola’s parents do the best they can in her situation – making Max have weekly meals with them, keeping track of what they’re doing in a non-invasive way. Lola admits that they know if they enforce anything harsher or make them stop seeing each other it would only push them closer. It doesn’t stop her lying and sneaking around though despite the trust they’ve put in her.

Her dads were great characters, and I really enjoyed their scenes and their relationship with Lola and one another. They were fun and interesting and supportive. The Norah element was interesting and spread nicely through the story. You can definitely see Lola being burned before by her birth mother and being the selfish person she is having little understanding of what it means beyond her own feelings.

Aside from the Max thing, the actual story was fine. Lola is a quirky girl who goes to extreme effort in her outfits and how she presents herself. It’s amazing she gets away with it at school, but it is a creative hobby for her.

The whole story arc with Cricket and his family was interesting and I liked how it naturally came together by the end. I can see how everyone thinks it’s sweet and it is, but at the same time Lola doesn’t deserve Cricket. He’s too nice for her.

So much of the praise for this book goes towards Lola and her relationship with Cricket, which isn’t for most of the book. She’s angry at him, wary of him, slowly comes to be ok with him all while still dating Max. Her issues with him are valid, though her absolute fear at them returning was a tad over the top.

Once the story focused more on Cricket and Lola’s friendship the story was better, with a title like this you know how it will end, I just wish there’s been a better way to get them together without having to read about creepy Max. There was enough hurt feelings and history to build on where we didn’t need to normalise that kind of relationship.

You can purchase Lola and the Boy Next Door via the following

QBDDymocks | Booktopia

WorderyBlackwell’s | Angus & Robertson

Fishpond | Amazon | Amazon Aust | Audible

The end of NaNoWriMo

I’m not sure how much I have mentioned it on the blog over the years but I have been a massive fan of the National Novel Writing Month for many years. After being introduced to in back at university I have been an active and enthusiastic participant since 2008 and I have looked forward to November every year since as I take the chance to write.

In that time I have finished very few novels but I always hit the 50k mark. I have written stories that were easy, some that were like pulling teeth and every ten, hundred, thousand words was torturous. I have written stories that I based off songs, based off a dream, based off playing The Sims. I’ve tried my hand at fantasy, historical, short stories, contemporary, and romance. I have 50 thousand plus words written for each of these ideas and so many more that I think of fondly. Of these numerous stories I have even developed three of them into actual edited, structured, novels. I have thought about them for years, tinkered, fiddled with, restructured and pondered over some for more than a decade as the idea wouldn’t leave me. Nano is incredibly important to me. So much so I associate warm weather with writing and often get my most writing done on warm sunny days. I think I associate it with sitting in front of my computer each November writing every single day for hours on end.

But all of that is changing. The announcement came in my inbox at 9am on 1 April via email that Nano was coming to an end. I had to check the current time in the USA to determine if it was a poor taste joke or whether the US hadn’t entered April yet. Alas, it was not a joke. As a non-profit organisation NaNoWriMo relies on donations in part, each year they are involved with the P4A project and you can donate through their website and have been able to for many years. However it seems that isn’t enough as the Nano team cited financial issues as the cause of their closure.

There have been are a lot of factors in the past as well, I know they had a major issue with their forums and moderation which resulted in an overhaul of how the site worked and the forums ran, but even then it kept going. The sad thing is, even if there has been a slump in finances, many believe the final nail in the coffin was their support of the use of AI in writing which resulted in obvious backlash. In the video they released it adds a bit more confusion on the exact reasons for the final closure. Those more knowledgeable than I can look at their graphs and finances, but you can also read between the lines and work out what it all means and what their reasons really are. At the moment I’m happy to sit on the sidelines and just be sad and annoyed about the whole thing.

It’s not new that Nano has been different in the past few years. The change of the website and forum set up felt different to the numerous years spent chatting in topic forums about specialist hobbies for a character, or sharing titles, sharing character names, going into the genre specific areas to share fantasy ideas and concepts. The shout outs for hitting 1k, 5k, 40k were always fun to revisit and see how far ahead or behind you were with other people and your month’s projections, not to mention the “coffee shop” forums where you could escape writing for a while and chat about other things. I still have an entire bulging folder (as bulging as an online folder can be) of the Nano encouragement emails that used to come out from various famous authors over the years. Those little reminders to keep going were wonderful and often had a lot of inspiration and advice as well. They felt less common than they used to be too.

Participating in Nano wasn’t confined to the website. You could talk to people online and share stories and encouragement without ever opening up the website or a forum. A hashtag on any social platform and a conversation could give you a writing buddy across the world. People all over were talking about and making things connected to Nano, it was a great community. I fell in love with Nanotoons which was started by Debbie Ridpath Ohi and continued by Errol Elumir. I came in with Errol’s run and it made me wish for a write-in near me I could join and become immersed in the fun and games of community writing. I loved getting the emails each year and loved following the characters on their writing journey alongside my own.

Even with all the changes there’s no denying how impactful Nano can be on a writer. Nano famously was the place many novels were started. There’s articles and lists, a Goodreads category, even a bookshop section for books that were written during Nano. It’s wonderful to see that the pain and panic of trying to write 50k in a month (an “easy” 1667 words per day) can accomplish something great.

Lifetime word count

In my time participating I started 17 books, and I have continued to work on 3 of them. Which isn’t a huge percentage but it doesn’t mean the others are forgotten either. I have so many memories on this blog, as well as other places like Facebook, Tumblr, and even Twitter back in the day of sharing my goals, my achievements, and my frustrations and elations that it will be strange not to have an official website to work with.

It does feel like, even though they were years apart, the writing traditions and community I have enjoyed since I started using Nano in 2008 are gone. My beloved WriteorDie, a staple for many Nanoers, after numerous changes and updates finally shutdown entirely. A quiet and surprising end to something so integral to my writing experiences. NaNotoons ended in 2018 which was a shining light in my inbox each November, and now Nano itself is gone.

Of course no one can stop you writing a novel in November, but there was a comfort in a website, having a goal, the new badges that came in recently to add some fun and challenges and retrospection on writing styles. Not to mention chatting with others who were just as keen, just as frustrated, just as stuck and creative as you were. I could have written this post about the memories of my projects, the challenges each one had, the fun I had finding a new inspirational quote each year, and competing against buddies and their writing stats. How I would write summaries for books I hadn’t written yet, design covers, and would vary between having a full story and no title or a title and no story. I could talk about the winners certificates I was so proud of, the winner goodies, and the banners I spread across the socials. How I got writing software I still use and how I saved all my stats to look back on my achievements each year. But then I could be writing forever.

As a worldwide community event that started in 1999, NaNoWriMo recently celebrated its 25th anniversary. It has brought people together in write-ins, across the globe and in local communities as people found support, buddy systems, encouragement and ideas sharing and it is a shame it won’t survive long enough to even see out the 2025 event.

I don’t know where we will all end up but hopefully there will be a migration somewhere else where we can continue to build on the writing community that we’ve grown to love over the decades. If there’s one thing I’ve noticed is the writing community will always find one another and the writing will persevere.

Previous Older Entries Next Newer Entries